The question is: Should the government provide student loan forgiveness to stimulate the economy? While such a measure would be good for the economy, it might not be as good for student borrowers. There are many reasons why student loan forgiveness would not be a good idea. For example, the burden of debt is often the cause of lower household formation and higher delinquency rates. It also contributes to borrowers’ poorer confidence in the future. Therefore, while this program would be good for the middle class, there are significant drawbacks.
In addition to benefiting borrowers, student loan forgiveness is controversial. Forgiveness does not erase the debt, it merely shifts it to future taxpayers, those who did not borrow the money in the first place. It also imposes additional costs on future taxpayers, who will have to pay for those costs, not to mention the ones who will never be able to afford a college education. And while student loan forgiveness is a good thing for the economy, it could also lead to higher levels of debt among future students.
The proposed legislation will provide a ten-year grace period. However, the threshold for loan forgiveness is too low and will not work for everyone. Besides, the student debt forgiveness plan would also be costly, as students will have to pay a lifetime of interest. The government should look at student debt forgiveness as a good way to spur the economy and help people achieve the dream of a successful career.
While many Americans have high hopes for the student debt forgiveness program, there are significant downsides. For one, it would require the government to purchase privately held student loans. The government would then be liable for 2% of GDP. That would increase the fiscal deficit by 0.4% by 2019 – a significantly higher figure than the current estimate. The positive side is that most students would benefit from this initiative. It would also benefit the economy by reducing income inequality and boosting home ownership rates.
Student loan debt causes weak creditworthiness, a reduction in spending and consumption, and a widening of income disparity. Furthermore, student debt prevents many borrowers from making the type of decisions that would stimulate the economy and create jobs. Furthermore, it is psychologically draining to hold onto debt and not be able to invest in anything. If the government does grant student loan forgiveness, it can help the young generation to tap the benefits of having a home and improving their lifestyles.
For millions of American borrowers, student debt is a stifling economic burden. A full-on student debt cancellation would boost the economy by between $115 and $400 billion a year – an increase of $90 billion in cash flow over the next five years. However, such a measure would be costly for the government and may benefit only the rich. However, it is important to keep in mind that this stimulus measure would have far fewer positive effects on the economy than other stimulus measures.
A recent Brookings study estimates that only 7% of student loan borrowers qualify for the program. This suggests that the majority of eligible borrowers have higher incomes than the general population. Even if the government were to implement a $10,000 student loan forgiveness plan, it would still result in an aggregate savings of $400 billion. This amount represents a fraction of the total debt that Americans have accumulated over the past decade.
Another factor in deciding whether or not to provide student loan forgiveness to stimulate the economy is the amount of money the federal government has spent on Pell Grant recipients over the past decade. In fact, a government-sponsored program is worth about $1.2 trillion, but it has the potential to spur the economy. However, the policy doesn’t always work as well as many advocate. Moreover, it doesn’t work for students with high incomes because the federal government’s money will go largely to subsidize higher-income students.
While federal students are entitled to a free education, the costs of providing student debt forgiveness to everyone would be far greater than any savings they might realize. However, this policy would benefit millions of Americans, reducing their financial burden and costing the federal government a great deal in lost payments. In addition, if the federal government was to provide student loan forgiveness to all borrowers, it would cost nearly $245 billion per borrower. If the federal government were to provide student loan debt forgiveness to everyone, this policy would result in a massive economic stimulus.
See our certificates and courses here.
© Photo by Shutterstock.com
